Partick Thistle 0 Dunfermline 3Saturday, 21st Sep 2019
Ladbrokes. Championship: two changes as Ryan Dow and Gabby McGill come in for Tom Beadling and Lewis McCann. Kevin Nisbet (23) 0-1: Ryan Dow (32) 0-2: Kyle Turner (49) 0-3:
For the second week running the Pars face Thistle but this time it was the Partick one and it would be tenth placed Fifers against ninth placed Jags. Following a run of poor league performances and results, the Firhill board took a unanimous decision in midweek to terminate the contracts of manager Gary Caldwell and his assistant Brian Kerr.
The interim management of Gerry Britton, Scott Allison and Kenny Miller made two changes for Thistle, Cammy Palmer and Tommy Robson dropped to the bench as Stuart Bannigan and Shea Gordon started. Former Pars fans favourite Joe Cardle was making his 26th appearance for Thistle but other former Par, Ryan Williamson was on the bench - ousted at right back by 22 year old Osman Kakay on loan from Queens Park Rangers.
Stevie Crawford also made two changes to his starting eleven. Ryan Dow returned after missing three weeks through injury and 19 year old Gabby McGill came in for his first Championship start. After having to go off against Inverness the previous week, Josh Edwards was fit to resume at left back meaning Lewis Martin and Lee Ashcroft formed the central defence.
Before the kick off there was one minute applause in respect of the late Rangers legend Fernando Rickson and it was McGill who got things underway with the Pars playing from south to north.
The visitors enjoyed much of the possession in the opening minutes although it was a Cardle cross from the right for Miller that created the first danger. Thistle kept up the pressure with a fifth minute break into the left side of the box by Dario Zanatta whose cut back was well cut out by the defence before it could reach Gordon.
Dunfermline made Scott Fox pull off the first save of the match from a Kevin Nisbet header after Dow had taken a short pass from McGill wide right. Cammy Gill has to react sharply when again Zanatta and Gordon threatened from the left side of the Pars box but thankfully the keeper got to the squirming low ball.
Greg Kiltie’s challenge on Kakay awarded Thistle an eleventh minute free kick midway into their opponents’ half, and although they did little with it they did maintain the pressure in the Pars half. A Gordon pass in from the right set up Miller for a 15th minute shot 20 yards out and with the home fans screaming ‘hit it’ he sent the ball high over Gill’s bar.
For the Jags Reece Cole flashed a 21st minute corner kick through the Pars box before two minutes later the home side were caught out by a slick Pars move. Dow threaded the ball onto the path of Aaron Comrie overlapping up the right and his early cross was met by NISBET 15 yards out to fire the ball into the bottom left of the Thistle net with Fox unable to get to it. 0-1
The goal certainly gave Dunfermline the lift they required and Nisbet powered another shot over the crossbar. Dow was unlucky not to get past his man as the Fifers tried to further exploit the weakness on the Thistle left.
Edwards 30th minute corner from the right was only partially defended and Nisbet rattled the crossbar with another great effort. The second Pars goal was only minutes away however and it was a tremendous solo effort from DOW. He ran in on a diagonal run from the right and as no one was able to stop him reached the inside of the Partick box to fire low into the bottom right. Fox was beaten and Kakay could do nothing on the line to prevent the goal. 0-2
The second goal deflated the home fans in great contrast to the 471 strong, travelling support who were in full song. Thistle needed to get back into the game before the interval but Comrie headed away Cole’s corner. James Penrice experienced the wrath of the home fans for needlessly pushing over Comrie when in an attacking position. Frustrations were evident both on and off the park.
Next Zanatta delivered a dangerous cross from the left and it looked like Thistle had to score but somehow between them Edwards and Gill scrambled the ball away. Then in 42 minute Gill held a Cardle effort from 25 yards.
There had been five shots from both sides but Dunfermline had three on target to Thistle’s one and of course the significant goals had been for the visitors.
Half time: Partick Thistle 0 Dunfermline 2
Lewis McCann replaced Gabby McGill and for Thistle Lewis Mansell came on for Shea Gordon before the second half got going. The Fifers were to extend their lead in just the fourth minute of the half. Dow was slipped the ball from Kiltie who had popped up beside him on the right and Thistle paid for the stopping the cross. McCann could have been the impact hero but 15 yards out he failed to get a proper connection but the ball was fed back to TURNER who thrashed a shot on target, albeit with the assistance of a deflection, to bulge the net from 25 yards out. 0-3
Dow and Nisbet combined out on the right and another cross was sent into the Jags box but just too much height on it for McCann to convert. Raffaele De Vita was introduced in place of Joe Cardle in 56 minutes but still the Pars pressed and a move from Kiltie on the left, through Turner to Dow and ultimately Nisbet almost created another good opening but only a goal kick resulted.
Dow was withdrawn in 61 minutes and Tom Beadling became the second Pars sub of the day. Turner forced a corner but that changed nothing and then Nisbet looped a pass into a central area that Kiltie just failed to get a grip of.
Dunfermline were successfully thwarting Thistle’s attempts to get near Gill’s goal and the home fans were very quite and steadily reducing in numbers as Kiltie picked out Nisbet and from the edge of the box, he whistled a 73rd minute shot narrowly wide right.
Harry Cochrane was the final Pars sub used with eleven minutes remaining and he immediately linked with McCann to send the striker through to release a powerful effort that just cleared the bar from 25 yards out.
Beadling headed away a 90th minute corner from Cole but the Pars had totally frustrated Thistle with solid and hard worked defending. The outcome had really been settled early in the second half but this was a welcome and well deserved win, the first in the league since March.
More important the three points elevated Dunfermline to seventh and secured a confidence boosting victory.
SUBS NOT USED: Cammy Palmer, Ryan Williamson, Steven Saunders, Jamie Sneddon (GK).
DUNFERMLINE: Cammy Gill: Aaron Comrie, Lee Ashcroft, Lewis Martin, Josh Edwards: Ryan Dow (Tom Beadling 61), Paul Paton (c), Kyle Turner, Greg Kiltie (Harry Cochrane 79), Gabby McGill (Lewis McCann HT), Kevin Nisbet.
SUBS NOT USED: Josh Coley, Andy Ryan, Stuart Morrison, Ryan Scully (GK)
SCORERS: Nisbet (23), Dow (32), Turner (49)
REFEREE: Euan Anderson
WEATHER: Sunny 22C
NEXT MATCH: Ladbrokes Championship: (home) v Alloa Athletic, Saturday 28th September 2019, 3.00pm kick off at East End Park
Views : 5,238
Partick Thistle 0-3 Dunfermline
Sat, 21st Sep 2019
Stevie Crawford post Partick Thistle
Sat, 21st Sep 2019
Ryan Dow post Partick Thistle
Sat, 21st Sep 2019
Check out the Gallery for more photo's -- the images below will scroll through automatically.
Preview Partick ThistleSaturday, 21st Sep 2019
Ladbrokes Championship: (away) v Partick Thistle, Saturday 21st September 2019 kick off 3.00pm at the Energy Check Stadium at Firhill.
It’s just the sixth league fixture of the season but for Dunfermline and Partick Thistle this is looking like a must win game. Neither side has had a league victory, both have two points courtesy of two drawn games.
Dunfermline have picked up one point off Dundee and Queen of the South, Partick off Alloa Athletic and Arbroath. Before leaving his position as Thistle manager on Wednesday, Gary Caldwell appeared as frustrated as Stevie Crawford. Caldwell lamented after his team’s last outing at Arbroath that his players are doing all the right things on the training pitch but just not turning it on the park.
Having seen his side rely heavily on the work of keeper Scott Fox, Caldwell singled out performance and mentality as particularly worrying. Jags and Pars are two points behind Alloa Athletic in eighth place and maybe it will be more important for both not to lose this match.
Milestones Partick (away)
Last League Victory | 25/09/10 | 2-0 | First Div
Last League Defeat | 08/12/18 | 0-2 | Championship
Best League Victory | 20/04/66 | 6-2 | Div One*
Worst League Defeat | 10/11/34 | 1-7 | Div One*
*Pre league reconstruction
In the previous 86 league meetings Dunfermline have won 35, Partick 27 and 24 have been drawn but at Firhill the home side has the upper hand with 18 wins to 14.
Dunfermline v Partick Thistle: The Full League Record
P | W | D | L | For | Agst
44 | 21 | 14 | 9 | 73 | 57 | At East End Park
42 | 14 | 10 | 18 | 52 | 73 | At Firhill
45 | 18 | 14 | 13 | 77 | 72 | Division One (up to 1975)
6 | 3 | 1 | 2 | 8 | 10 | Premier Division (since 1975)
30 | 12 | 7 | 11 | 32 | 40 | First Division (since 1975)
4 | 2 | 1 | 0 | 4 | 3 | Championship
86 | 35 | 24 | 27 | 126 | 129 | TOTALS
Last Twelve League Matches v Partick Thistle
The last dozen league games between the teams have seen Dunfermline win three, drawn four and lost five.
Date | H/A | F-A | Scorers
06/04/19 A 2-2 [1-0] Beadling: [2-0] Anderson: [1-2] Blair (og): [2-2] McDonald.
28/02/19 H 3-0 [1-0] Anderson, [2-0] Devine, [3-0] Anderson
08/12/18 A 0-2 [0-1] Spittal, [0-2] Storey.
28/09/18 H 1-0 [1-0] Connolly
27/04/13 A 3-3 [0-1] McMillan, [1-1] Wallace, [2-1] Thomson, [3-1] Thomson, [2-3] Erskine, [3-3] Lawless.
02/03/13 H 0-4 [0-1] Craig, [0-2] Forbes, [0-3] Craig, [0-4] Craig.
10/11/12 A 1-5 [0-1] Lawless, [1-1] Muirhead og, [1-2] Balatoni, [1-3] O`Donnell, [1-4] Forbes, [1-5] Lawless.
18/08/12 H 0-1 [0-1] Lawless
26/03/11 H 0-0
29/01/11 A 0-2 [0-1] [0-2]
14/12/10 H 0-0
25/09/10 A 2-0 [1-0] Clarke, [2-0} Kirk.
Last meeting at Firhill
Partick Thistle 2 Dunfermline 2
6 April 2019, Ladbrokes Championship
Jackson Longridge won a ninth minute corner that Blair lobbed high into the box and although Lee Ashcroft rose to meet it Thistle got the ball away. Louis Longridge regained possession on the left and picked out Tom BEADLING in the left side of the box. He took a touch before burying his shot in the bottom right. 0-1
A second Pars goal followed in 24 minutes from a corner on the right after Faisal El Bakhtaoui ‘s shot had been turned into the sidenetting. Louis Longridge took the setpiece and Bruce ANDERSON timed his run to meet the low cross and steered the ball in at the far post. 0-2
The warnings were there and Thistle got a goal back in 31 minutes. James Penrice passed to Scott McDonald on the left side of the penalty box and his firm strike along the six yard line cut out the keeper only for Ryan BLAIR tracking back to turn the ball into his own net. 1-2
Thistle grabbed the equaliser in 77 minutes when sub Miles Storey’s pass to pick out McDONALD was deflected off the chest of James Craigen over Danny Devine and on for the striker to net. 2-2
PARTICK THISTLE: Conor Hazard: Jack McMillan (Joe Cardle HT), Steven Anderson, Steven Saunders (Aidan Fitzpatrick 75), James Penrice, Sean McGinty, Blair Spittal, Stuart Bannigan (c), Shea Gordon (Miles Storey 70), Kris Doolan, Scott McDonald.
SUBS NOT USED: Craig Slater, Lewis Mansell, Gary Harkins, Jamie Sneddon (GK).
DUNFERMLINE: Ryan Scully: James Craigen, Lee Ashcroft (c), Danny Devine, Jackson Longridge: Tom Beadling: Matthew Todd (Ryan Williamson 56), Ryan Blair, Louis Longridge: Faissal El Bakhtaoui (Myles Hippolyte 83), Bruce Anderson (Lewis McCann 86).
SUBS NOT USED: Mark Durnan, James Vincent, Kallum Higginbotham, Cammy Gill (GK)
Form Last Six Matches
Inverness Caley Thistle (H) L 0-1
Alloa Athletic (H) L 1-2
Arbroath (A) L 0-1
Dundee United (H) L 0-2
Celtic (A) L 1-2 AET
Queen of the South (A) D 1-1
Arbroath (A) D 1-1
Montrose (A) W 2-0
Ayr United (H) L 2-3
Morton (A) L 2-3
Ross County (H) W 3-2
Dundee United (H) L 1-2
Partick Thistle are unbeaten in this season’s cup competitions but they are still seeking their first league win. With just two draws they are level on points with Dunfermline at the foot of the table.
After a confidence building Betfred campaign where they won their group and defeated Premier League opponents St Mirren, and an impressive display against Dundee and Celtic, Dunfermline are now seeking to end a run of seven matches without a win.
League Position: 10th
League Points: 2
Goal Difference: -4
League Record: P5 W0 D2 L3 GF3 GA7
Last Six Match Form: DDLLLL
League Position: 9th
League Points: 2
Goal Difference: -3
League Record: P5 W0 D2 L3 GF7 GA10
Last Six Match Form: LDLLWD
Above: Ryan Williamson and Joe Cardle are both now at Partick Thistle
Last time out
DUNFERMLINE (v Inverness Caley Thistle): Cammy Gill: Aaron Comrie, Lee Ashcroft, Lewis Martin, Josh Edwards (Danny Devine 77): Tom Beadling, Paul Paton (c), Kyle Turner (Harry Cochrane 72), Lewis McCann (Josh Coley 72), Greg Kiltie, Kevin Nisbet.
SUBS NOT USED: Andy Ryan, Gabby McGill, Matty Todd, Ryan Scully (GK)
PARTICK THISTLE (v Arbroath): Scott Fox: Osman Kakay, Tom O`Ware, McGinty, James Penrice: Reece Cole, Cameron Palmer, Tommy Robson (Raffaele De Vita 40), Joe Cardle (Lewis Mansell 63), Kenny Miller, Dario Zanatta
SUBS NOT USED: Ryan Williamson, Ben Hall, Mouhamed Niang, Steven Saunders, Jamie Sneddon (GK).
Other Championship Fixtures
Alloa Athletic v Ayr United
Dundee United v Arbroath
Inverness Caledonian Thistle v Queen of the South
Morton v Dundee
- Dunfermline 0 Inverness Caley Thistle 1
- Dunfermline 1 Alloa Athletic 2
- There’s Been a Murder!
- Lifeline Winners – 14 September 2019